Florida’s Gateway City to the Keys: One of the State’s Most Dangerous Areas

When it comes to Florida, the Keys are surely one of the state’s greatest gems. These idyllic little islands run south from the mainland, are surrounded by the shimmering, turquoise waters of the Caribbean, and are known for white sand beaches, palm trees, and laid-back vibes as captured in songs such as Jimmy Buffet’s “Margaritaville.”

Key West, the southernmost island in the chain, is the most iconic destination, and even though it can get pricey, there are ways to visit on a budget. However, the gateway to the Keys remains Florida City, a settlement of around 12,500 that is the last stop on the mainland until you hit the islands.

While some people make Florida City their base for exploring the Keys, others just stop to stock up on supplies or grab a bite to eat before heading further south. Though the city certainly offers many conveniences, it has also earned a much more unsavory distinction that may have you thinking twice about pulling off the interstate. It’s ranked as one of the most dangerous cities in Florida.

According to the security company Sirix Monitoring, Florida City has the highest violent crime rate in all of the state, with 17.56 incidents per 1,000 people — six times the average. With a relatively small population, Florida City logged 226 violent crimes and 585 property crimes in 2024, which means — according to statistics — you have a one in 56 chance of becoming a victim. This may have you watching which streets you walk down after dark or looking over your shoulder when withdrawing cash from the ATM. 

Why is Florida City such a dangerous place? What makes crime stats go off the charts like they do in this unexpected Florida city regarded as one of the most dangerous in America? One of the main factors is poverty, as 41.2% of Florida City locals live below the poverty line. The area’s relatively lax gun laws may also play a part, as firearms are plentiful and easy to get throughout much of the Sunshine State.

Another factor pushing up crime rates in Florida City is tourism. Florida attracted over 140 million visitors in 2024, and such an influx of people (who are often seen by the locals as being flush with cash) provides an irresistible target for thieves, scammers, and muggers. Florida’s tourist towns generally see a higher crime rate than the less-visited parts of the state, and Florida City — as the gateway to both the Keys and the Everglades — gets its fair share of visitors.